“Connor… You were going to ask me to prom? Even more, you were going to tell me that you loved me…?”
He didn’t meet my eyes.
“It doesn’t matter now, Pam. It never did.”
“But all these years…” My voice cracked.
“You cared about me?”
Connor finally looked at me, his expression pained but resolute.
“Of course I did.
But you were happy with Caleb, and that’s what mattered. That’s all that ever mattered.”
Tears streamed down my face as I tried to process what I’d just seen and heard. “Why didn’t you tell me?”
Connor shook his head, giving me a sad smile.
“Because you were already where you wanted to be.
And I couldn’t ruin that.”
The room felt heavy with unspoken words. I didn’t know what to say, and for once, Connor didn’t fill the silence.
We both stared at the frozen image on the screen, young Connor standing alone in the shadows while I walked away, blissfully unaware.
We returned to the living room, where Caleb was still glued to the TV, oblivious to everything.
But something inside me had shifted.
I sat next to Connor, stealing glances at him as he pretended everything was fine. The memory of that night, of his quiet heartbreak, lingered in my mind.
“Connor,” I whispered.
“You’ve always been there for me.
I see that now. You’ve always been more than a friend, haven’t you?”
“Pam, please,” he said, his voice breaking. “Let it go.”
I bit my lip, unsure of what to do.
My heart was torn between the familiarity of Caleb and the quiet, unwavering love Connor had always shown me.
“Maybe in another life,” I said softly.
“Maybe,” Connor replied, his smile bittersweet.
That night, I lay awake, wondering what could’ve been.
For the first time, I questioned everything I thought I knew about love—and what it meant to be truly seen.
Tell us what you think about this story, and share it with your friends. It might inspire them and brighten their day.
