“Everly,” I began cautiously, “who’s in that photo in the kitchen?
The one with the little girl?”
She looked puzzled for a second, then smiled. “Oh, that’s me and my mom. Why?”
My stomach dropped.
“Your mom?” I asked, my voice shaky.
“Yeah, that’s my mom. Why do you ask?”
I felt dizzy. I had no idea how to say what I was thinking.
My words tumbled out. “That’s my mom too.”
Everly’s smile faded. “What do you mean?
That’s my mom.”
“No, I mean… that woman in the photo. That’s my mom.”
Everly stared at me, trying to process what I had just said.
“Are you sure?” she asked slowly.
“I’m positive. That’s her.
The same face, the same smile… everything.”
Everly stood frozen, her eyes wide with disbelief. Neither of us knew what to say next. We just stood there in shock, staring at each other, as the weight of what we had just uncovered started to sink in.
We began comparing stories, trying to piece together our pasts.
“When were you born?” I asked.
“1996,” she said quietly.
I nodded. “I was born in ’91. So I’m older.
But I don’t remember her saying anything about another family. Do you know where she was living when you were little?”
Everly thought for a moment. “We lived in a different city when I was born.
Mom said we moved here when I was five, after she got a new job.”
“I remember Mom traveling for work when I was little,” I said, rubbing my forehead as I tried to recall the details. “She was gone a lot when I was around eight or nine. That would’ve been… 2002, maybe 2003.”
Everly’s eyes widened.
“Wait. In 2003, my grandmother told me my mom was coming to visit more often. I remember because that was when I started school.
She’d come every few months, stay for a few days, then leave again.”
My heart began to race. “Mom used to say she had long work projects in other cities. She would be gone for weeks.
I thought it was normal at the time, but now… I’m wondering if those trips were to see you.”
Everly nodded slowly. “She’d always bring me little gifts when she visited. I remember one time — this must’ve been in 2005 — she gave me a necklace from New York City.
I asked her where she’d been, but she never really gave me an answer.”
“That was the same year she brought me back a snow globe from a trip to New York,” I said, my voice trembling. “She told me she went for a conference.”
Everly buried her head in her hands. “Do you think she… do you think she kept us apart on purpose?”
I swallowed hard.
“I don’t know. But we need to find out.”
A week later, my mom came to visit. I hadn’t said anything about Everly yet, but I had already arranged for her to come over that afternoon.
My heart was racing as I waited for the confrontation.
When my mom arrived, she greeted me with a warm hug. We sat in the living room, making small talk while my mind raced.
Then the doorbell rang. I opened it, and Everly stepped in.
My mom’s eyes widened when she saw her.
“Mom,” I started, my voice trembling, “I made friends with my neighbor, Everly. And we found something… strange.”
My mom’s face changed, and her expression was tight with worry. “What do you mean?” she asked carefully.
Everly and I exchanged a glance.
“I found a picture of you at her house,” I said, watching my mom closely. “She said you’re her mom, too.”
Her face went pale. She sat down slowly, her hands trembling in her lap.
She opened her mouth to speak, but no words came out.
“Mom,” I pressed, “is it true?”
After what felt like an eternity, she finally whispered, “Yes.”
I could barely breathe. “Why didn’t you ever tell me? How could you keep something like this from us?”
Tears welled up in her eyes.
“I… I didn’t want it to come out like this. I was trying to protect you both.”
“Protect us?” Everly’s voice rose. “From what?
From each other?”
My mom looked at us, her face etched with regret. “I was in love with someone else when I had you, Everly,” she said softly. “He was my boss.
It was an affair. I didn’t plan it, but when I got pregnant, everything changed. I couldn’t stay.
His wife didn’t know about you, and I had to leave before things got worse.”
Everly’s jaw dropped. “So you left me behind? You just disappeared?”
“No,” my mom said, her voice breaking.
“I never left you completely. His mother helped raise you. I visited, but I couldn’t stay long.
I had to go back to my life, to my family. It was complicated. I thought I was doing the right thing.”
“The right thing?” I couldn’t help but snap.
“You had two daughters, and you chose to hide one of us from the other.”
“I thought it was the only way,” she cried. “I was terrified. I didn’t know how to handle it.
And by the time I realized what I had done, it was too late. You were both growing up in different worlds. I didn’t know how to bring you together without ruining everything.”
We sat there, the weight of her words sinking in.
I felt anger, sadness, and confusion all at once. How could she have done this? How could she have kept us apart for so long?
Everly wiped a tear from her cheek.
“You robbed us of so much time,” she said quietly. “We could’ve known each other. We could’ve been sisters.”
My mom looked at us, guilt written all over her face.
“I know,” she whispered. “And I’m so, so sorry. I can’t take back what I did.
But I’m begging you both… please, give me a chance to make it right.”
After the confrontation, Everly and I sat in silence. Our mom had left, promising she would try to fix things, but we both knew that no amount of apologies could erase the years we lost. The truth had changed everything.
“I still can’t believe it,” Everly said, her voice barely above a whisper.
“I have a sister.”
I nodded, feeling the same mix of emotions. “It’s hard to process.”
“But,” she said, looking at me with a small smile, “maybe we can start over. You know… as sisters.”
I smiled back, though my heart still felt heavy.
“Yeah. I think we can try.”
We didn’t know what the future held, but we knew one thing for sure — we had each other now. And that was a start.
Source: amomama
